Pharos Terminal

History course

Long Shadows: What the Presidents' Hardest Choices Left Behind

18-Week History Course

Abraham Lincoln, seated, facing front, in a dark suit, one arm resting on a table.
Abraham Lincoln, seated portrait, facing front, January 8, 1864. Mathew Brady’s studio. Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division, LC-DIG-ppmsca-19211. View the original

The record, from every side

Your student reads what each president and his critics said and did, in their own words: messages, proclamations, statutes, treaties, court opinions, petitions, protests and government data. The strongest defense and the strongest criticism are each stated in the terms of their own time before anyone judges the decision. Republicans, Democrats, a Federalist and a Democratic-Republican get the same questions, the same ledger and the same rubric, and every claim traces to a source printed in the lesson.

For the parent or teacher

Each lesson’s parent note says what to preview that day, and every lesson has a full answer key.

Course Big Question

When a president makes a controversial decision, how should we weigh what it cost at the time against what it left behind?

Course introduction

Presidents are remembered for their controversies, and reputations rise and fall. Grant, once dismissed for scandal, is now credited for breaking the Klan. Wilson, once ranked near the top, is now judged more harshly. This course does not hand students a ranking. It gives them one method and asks them to use it on 16 presidents from four parties and four centuries, the same way each time.

For each president, students take one controversy: a decision that divided the country when it was made. They first define it in neutral words. Then they build the strongest case for it, as its defenders made it at the time, and the strongest case against it, as its critics made it at the time. In the second lesson they follow the decision forward: what happened within the term, within a generation, and down to today. That includes effects on people who were not in the headlines and costs that were not seen at first. They finish with a ledger that sets the controversy against the long-term impact, and they write a short verdict that says what evidence would change it.

The course is not about how much power presidents should have. That is the subject of Take Care: The American Presidents and the Power They Hold. Where the two courses meet, this course links to the Take Care lesson instead of repeating it.

From Washington and the Jay Treaty in 1795 to the Affordable Care Act in 2010: a method week, then one president a week in time order, each with the same two lessons, and a capstone week. Lesson A states the controversy in neutral words and gives the strongest defense and the strongest criticism, in the sources of the time. Lesson B follows the decision forward through the term, the next generation and down to today, and ends with the ledger and a verdict that says what evidence would change it. Every writing task has its own expectations for the Grades 7–8 path, Grades 9–10 and Grades 11–12. There are two DBQs, a midterm in Week 10 and a final in Week 18, and the capstone verdict is presented to the family in Week 18.

Grades 9–12, with a Grades 7–8 path. 18 weeks, two lessons a week of about 50–60 minutes, plus about 30 minutes of document reading three times a week. Aligned to West Virginia Department of Education academic standards (Social Studies and English Language Arts, grades 7–12).

The course opens with an active Pharos Terminal subscription.

Subscribe to start Lesson 1 Already a subscriber? Sign in

Pharos Terminal

Every course is included

This course is included with an active Pharos Terminal subscription, along with every other course, new courses as they’re released, new Nexus Points several times a week and the parent tracker. Lessons are aligned to West Virginia Department of Education academic standards in English Language Arts, Science and Social Studies.